Skip to content

PHAP online expert briefing on the end of armed conflict under IHL

February 4, 2016

Two years ago, I wrote on Opinio Juris (Part 1 and 2) and here on the blog about the end of non-international armed conflicts (NIACs). How do you determine when NIACs end? IHL is rather unclear as to its temporal scope of application for NIACs. Whilst there is – by now – extensive case law and a lot written on when a NIAC, and thus the application of IHL to it, starts, the case law is very limited when it comes to the end of such armed conflicts. Initially, there was nothing on this topic. Since these blog posts, my piece in this book, Marko Milanovic’s excellent article in the International Review of the Red Cross, and Julia Grignon’s equally excellent book (in French), have all discussed the end of the application of IHL applicable to NIACs, but there is not much out there. In its latest report on IHL and the challenges of contemporary armed conflicts, prepared in advance of the 2015 International Conference of the Red Cross and Red Crescent, the ICRC’s said the following:

In the ICRC’s practical experience, the cessation of all hostilities between the parties to the conflict and the absence of a real risk of their resumption – based on an overall assessment of the surrounding factual circumstances – have proven to provide the strongest and most reliable indicators that a NIAC has ended. The ICRC’s practice has thus been to wait for the complete cessation of hostilities between the parties to a NIAC before assessing, based on the surrounding factual circumstances, whether there is a real risk of resumption of hostilities. If there is no such risk, the conclusion is drawn that the NIAC at issue has come to an end.

Given the limited academic attention so far, the current project by the Harvard Law School Program on International Law and Armed Conflict (PILAC) on the “end” of armed conflicts is very welcome. On 23 February 2016, Professionals in Humanitarian Assistance and Protection (PHAP) organises an online expert briefing about this project. Those familiar with Lauterpacht’s famous quote on IHL will – like I did – smile when seeing the very appropriate title:

International law at the vanishing point of war

PHAP announces the briefing as follows:

In December 2014, President Obama said that the United States “combat mission in Afghanistan is ending, and the longest war in American history is coming to a responsible conclusion.” Yet over a year later hostilities continue. What are the stakes for humanitarian organizations in the ongoing application—or not—of international humanitarian law (IHL) in Afghanistan and in other contemporary armed conflicts? Does international law provide sufficient guidance for humanitarians and other battlefield actors to discern when today’s armed conflicts end? At this PHAP online IHL expert briefing, Naz Modirzadeh and Dustin Lewis, of the Harvard Law School Program on International Law and Armed Conflict (PILAC), will discuss initial PILAC research on the “end” of armed conflict under IHL. Among the issues they will explore are:

What are the IHL criteria pertaining to the end of armed conflict?

Who benefits, and who is disadvantaged, from a presumption of the continued application of IHL—both its more permissive and its more restrictive elements?

What is at stake for humanitarian actors, for the parties to the conflict, and for affected civilian populations?

I am looking forward to this very interesting event!


News Roundup – 3 February 2016

February 3, 2016

International Organizations Applaud the Initiation of the First Trial for Sexual Slavery and Violence During the Armed Conflict in Guatemala: The Sepur Zarco Case

Plan Colombia’s mixed legacy: coca thrives but peace deal may be on horizon

Dutch Lawyers File Complaint Against Buhari on alleged crimes in Biafra (Nigeria) at the ICC in The Hague

Security Council condemns ‘heinous’ terrorist attack in Nigeria attributed to Boko Haram

UN: ‘Waves of violence’ by rebels in eastern DR Congo forces thousands to flee

UN says Peacekeepers, Congo army to resume joint fight against Rwandan rebels

Foreign Policy op-ed: The Burundi Intervention That Wasn’t

African Union decides against peacekeepers for Burundi

Video summary of the Confirmation of Charges hearing of Ongwen at ICC

Georgia welcomes ICC investigation of Russia-Georgia war crimes, but Russia’s chief investigator slams the Hague Court’s interpretation of South Ossetia events

As Syria burns, Turkey’s Kurdish problem is getting worse

Radio debate (in Dutch) on criminality under Dutch law of Dutch citizen for killing ISIS members in Syria

US Secretary of State: ISIS pushed back in Iraq, Syria, but a threat in Libya, and Anti-ISIS Coalition to Intensify Efforts

Inside the Kurdish fighting forces: the U.S.’s proxy ground troops in the war against ISIS

Russian drone video shows destruction in Homs (Syria)

Syrian women have gathered to be trained on negotiations

Beth van Schaack over on Just Security: Mapping the Law That Applies to War Crimes in Syria

Syria opposition delegation arrives (late) for Geneva talks

UNHCHR: War crimes should not be part of any Syria amnesty

New Offensive by Assad’s Forces Overshadows Syria Peace Talks

Human Rights Watch: Possible War Crimes by Shia Militia in Iraq

Saudi Arabia says 375 civilians killed on its border in Yemen war

Islamic State radio station taken out in suspected U.S. strike in Afghanistan

9 killed, 12 wounded in suicide attack on Kabul police base

T.M.C. Asser Institute lecture, 11th February 2016

February 2, 2016

HILACAt 7pm next Thursday 11th February, I am giving a lecture on the accountability of armed groups under international law at the T.M.C. Asser Institute. In the lecture, I will examine the concept of accountability under international law and the relationship between international human rights law and international humanitarian law when holding armed groups to account. I will also consider when and how the practice of holding armed groups to account under human rights law, as opposed to international humanitarian law, is legitimate.

The lecture is open to the public and you are very welcome to attend.

Date: 11th February 2016

Starts: 19:00h

Fee: Free
Venue: T.M.C. Asser Instituut
Organiser: T.M.C. Asser Instituut, Amsterdam Center for International Law
and Het Nederlandse Rode Kruis
Address: R.J. Schimmelpennincklaan 20-22
The Hague

News Roundup – 28 January 2016

January 28, 2016

13 years, 1 billion dollars, 2 convictions: is the ICC worth it? 

Human Rights Watch, World Report 2015. 

Spanish police arrest nine suspected members of PKK group. 

Rule of law crushed in Libya as rival governments vie for power, ISIS spreads. 

Sudan says it has defeated rebel group, after two weeks of fighting. 

Salva Kiir, Machar should face sanctions: UN. 

LRA re-emerging in Central African Republic, bishop warns. 

News Roundup – 25 January 2016

January 25, 2016

UN Security Council creates mission to verify Colombia peacedeal. 

Syrian forces, helped by Russian airstrikes, seize rebel stronghold. 

Syria talks to seek ceasefire, excluding ISIL and Nusra. 

Syria peacetalks to start on Friday, UN says. 

Suicide attackers hit Cameroon marketplace. 

DRC: a Mai Mai armed movement changes its code of conduct following recommendations of Geneva Call. 

Amid military confrontation in Darfur, limited progress on resolving the conflict – UN peacekeeping chief. 

As deadline slips in South Sudan, UN chief urges African partners to revive peace process.

Children and Armed Conflict – Monthly Update January 2016

January 25, 2016

Pages from Pages from Watchlist-CAC-Monthly-Update-January-2016

News Roundup – 22 January 2016

January 22, 2016

Ban welcomes joint request by Colombia government and FARC to set up UN political office. 

Syrian opposition figure says talks off until Russian strikes stop. 

Kurds and Shias face off over Kirkuk in vacuum left by Iraqi army.

Ivory Coast: UN peacekeeping force reduced in light of country’s progress towards stability. 

Meeting Al-Shabaab’s exclusive leader. 

Can the UN patch things up in the Congo? 

Is Mozambique’s Renamo recruiting militia?


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 668 other followers